Today : Sunday - Sep 21, 2014, 07:33am (GMT+5.5)
All News  
Top News
National News
International News
Business News
Sports News
   » Cricket
   » Football
Entertainment News
Sci - Tech
Politics News
Health & Fitness
Gulf News
::| Latest News
News in Pictures

Reliance Communications has made full repayment of two loans amounting to $1 billion (around Rs 6,000 crore), during the quarter ended June 30.The repayments have been from the company's rupee resources.

Business News

Reliance Communication says equity in Swan was within limit

Wednesday - Aug 10, 2011, 06:31pm (GMT+5.5)
[+] Text [-]

New Delhi - Reliance Communications Wednesday told a special court here hearing the second generation (2G) spectrum allocation case that its holdings in Swan Telecom at the time of award of airwaves was well within the prescribed limits.

“No criminal case can be made out against Reliance Telecom. It held only 9.9 percent equity in Swan Telecom and that was much before it was granted spectrum-licence,” said Iqbal Chagla, counsel for the company, now renamed Reliance Communications.

"Swan Telecom cannot be held as an associate company of Reliance Telecom. It also did not have any say in deciding the board members," counsel told the special Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) court, presided over by Judge O.P. Saini.

The response was to the probe agency's charge that Reliance Telecom had co-promoted Swan Telecom as a front company to get past the norms at that time, which made all existing service providers ineligible for fresh spectrum in their current areas of operation.

“The guideline only prohibited an existing telecom company from holding shares in excess of 10 percent in another telecom company. We initially held 9.9 percent stake in Swan, and no case is made out against us,” the defence counsel said.

He also took an example to say the probe agency was biased towards Reliance Telecom.

“Idea Cellular applied for licences for Mumbai in 2005. At that time, Aditya Birla Group had 20.74 percent equity shares of Idea. Then, the group also had over 99 percent equity in Aditya Birla Telcom," said Chagla.

"Thus. Aditya Birla Group had substantial equity in both Idea and Aditya Birla Telcom. In this context, the group should have been rejected for a license. But no! It was granted the licence," he said, and added his client also had no criminal intent.

"Even assuming everything is against myself. At worst, I allegedly filed an ineligible application. But that could have been rectified or rejected. There can't be any charge of any corrupt act. No corrupt motive, no gain," he said.

“Also, the allegations are contradictory to statements by a prosecution witnesses who confirmed Reliance was holding less than 10 percent stake in Swan from inception. DB Realty, in fact, took over Swan much before A. Raja became the telecom minister.”

The probe agency, in its charges before the court, had alleged that Reliance Telecom and three of its officials -- Gautam Doshi, Hari Nair and Surendra Pipara -- had conspired with former telecom minister Raja and caused huge losses to the exchequer.

After Reliance Telecom concluded its arguments, Harshad Ponda, counsel for Doshi, resumed his arguments. Ponda said it was a usual practice for industrial houses to have investment arms.

"Having a shell company is nothing unusual. The CBI cannot allege that I am a part of a criminal conspiracy, and I cannot be booked under the Criminal Procedure Code," he said, adding that when Swan was issued spectrum, Reliance Telecom had no share in it.


Rating (Votes: )   

blog comments powered by Disqus

Related Articles:
» Kudankulam N-plant to reconnect to the grid Oct 26
» Rupee unchanged at 61.46
» Kerala Tourism takes Twitter route for campaign
» Onion prices to come down in next 10 days: Thomas
» Ratan Tata meets Sharma post FIPB nod for airline venture
» Mamata government selling onions at Rs.36 per kg
» Gold prices gaining by Rs 480 to Rs 32,410 per ten gram
» Mukesh Ambani remains richest Indian with assets of $18.9 billion
» Top 100 rich Indians' net worth rises to $250 billion
» Bharti Airtel board approves subsidiary merger
» Emirates expects to fly 70 mn passengers in 2020
» Japan's Olympus scales down India business projection
» Tewari pulls up Ludhiana officials over MGNREGA funds
» India-France trade can aid inclusive growth: Jaipal Reddy
» China to set up power equipment service centres in India
» Reduced arrival of onions behind price hike: Dikshit
» Shanta Kumar slams delay in export ban on onions
» Sri Lanka records strong tourist, remittance earnings
» Cochin airport investors set to reap profits
» Etihad Airways to double Colombo flights
» Jet Airways standalone losses jump eight-fold to Rs. 891 crore
» RBI receives $10.1 billion under forex swap window
» SBI to get Rs 2000 cr as part of Rs 14K cr banks fund infusion
» Mobile economy to add $400 billion to India GDP: GSMA
» Volvo launches next generation S60 and XC60

Other Articles:
Air travel service tax for Q1 at Rs.231.5 crore (10th Aug, 2011)
World Bank signs $648 mn loan agreement with Tehri (10th Aug, 2011)
Sensex closes above 17,000-mark, ends 272 points up (10th Aug, 2011)
Panel to probe Delhi Terminal-3 power failure (10th Aug, 2011)
Sensex closes 255 points higher (10th Aug, 2011)
NHPC's Q1 net profit up 47.19 percent (10th Aug, 2011)
Bharti Airtel appoints new CEOs (10th Aug, 2011)
Rural Electrification Corporation's Q1 net profit up 12.70 percent (10th Aug, 2011)
Reliance Communications says equity in Swan was within limits (10th Aug, 2011)
Sensex reclaims 17K level, up 273 pts on firm global cues (10th Aug, 2011)
Coming soon: New 800cc car from Maruti (10th Aug, 2011)
Yepme to turn fully-online men's fashion house (10th Aug, 2011)
Bharat Forge's Q1 net profit up 64 percent (10th Aug, 2011)
Sensex still in green, auto, realty and IT stocks gain (10th Aug, 2011)
Pandit says Citigroup now 'a different company' (10th Aug, 2011)
US to keep interest rates low until 2013; stocks zoom (10th Aug, 2011)
Cuba tourism revenues go up (10th Aug, 2011)
BlackBerry becomes a weapon for rioters in Britain (10th Aug, 2011)
Indian markets start in green, Asian cues positive (10th Aug, 2011)
Mahindra Satyam surges 15% on bourses (10th Aug, 2011)
Nokia Siemens Networks expands capacity (10th Aug, 2011)
Mukherjee pleased over stock market recovery (10th Aug, 2011)
Decline in global crude prices will help in managing inflation, says financial analyst (10th Aug, 2011)
US productivity drops 0.3 percent in Q2 (10th Aug, 2011)
Mahindra Satyam to exit American Depository Share programme (10th Aug, 2011)

Contact Us | Advertise with Us | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Terms of Use