Today : Saturday - Aug 30, 2014, 01:39pm (GMT+5.5)
All News  
Top News
National News
International News
Business News
Sports News
   » Cricket
   » Football
Entertainment News
Sci - Tech
Politics News
Health & Fitness
Gulf News
::| Latest News
News in Pictures

Seemingly unfazed at being ousted from the Asian Athletics Association, scam-tainted Suresh Kalmadi on Monday said losing the presidential re-election bid to Qatar’s Dahlan Jumaan Al-Hamad has actually given him a chance to work at the “grassroots” level.
“I have no issues today and I congratulate Mr Al-Hamad for being elected as President. I am rather relieved that I will be able to work at the grassroots level in athletics,” Mr. Kalmadi said after losing the vote during the ongoing AAA Congress in Pune.

National News

BJP's 'galaxy' - more liability than asset

Saturday - Jan 26, 2013, 12:51pm (GMT+5.5)
[+] Text [-]

For all of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Arun Jaitley's claim that his party has a "galaxy" of leaders, it has had to fall back on an old and controversial warhorse, Rajnath Singh, for the second time to be the party chief.

What this means is that, in actuality, the BJP's cupboard is bare so far as members of leadership potential are concerned. Moreover, the potential embraces a whole gamut of complicating factors.

As a result, there is no easy ascent to the top. The BJP's greasy pole, therefore, which is the phrase denoting upward mobility, is greasier than in most parties.

Nothing demonstrated the conflicting ingredients of the leadership battle than the rise and fall of Nitin Gadkari. If, in the Congress, the scions of the Nehru-Gandhi family parachute down to the top of the party pyramid, in the BJP, it is the patriarchs of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), who determine who will descend from above to take charge of the party.

The starkness of this choreographed procedure has been highlighted twice in Rajnath Singh's case. The first time was in 2006, when then party president L.K. Advani was ousted by the RSS for committing the unpardonable sin - in the saffron brotherhood's eyes - of praising Mohammed Ali Jinnah on a visit to Pakistan in 2005.

Even at the time, the choice raised eyebrows because Rajnath Singh was - and still is - regarded as a "provincial", the unflattering word used by Jaswant Singh when he was dismissed from the BJP for repeating Advani's folly of lauding Jinnah in a book.

But provincials are apparently the kind preferred by the RSS because they lack the faint traces of cosmopolitanism, which includes fluency in English, which the BJP leaders based in Delhi tend to acquire.

So, when Rajnath Singh's term ended in 2009, the RSS turned to another provincial in a state which is farther away from the national capital than Uttar Pradesh, which is Rajnath Singh's home province.

But, in choosing the little known Maharashtrian, the RSS hadn't considered how his business ventures will come to haunt him. The praise which a saffron scribe heaped on Gadkari's business acumen when he became president is unlikely to be repeated now.

What the toing and froing between Rajnath Singh and Gadkari show is that even if there are leaders in the BJP who consider themselves capable of being the chief, the special predilections of the RSS keep a lid on their aspirations. So, it isn't only the absence of secular credentials which is a hindrance to someone like Narendra Modi's prime ministerial hopes; the penchant of the RSS for the less sophisticated is another roadblock before the party's smooth functioning.

Gadkari's involvement in a scam also undermines the party's offensive against the Congress on the issue of corruption. Throughout the period when civil society activists were agitating on the subject, the BJP had to remain in the background because of the scandals surrounding its chief minister in Karnataka at the time, B.S. Yeddyurappa. Now, Yeddyurappa's exit from the BJP will not help the party much.

The BJP's hope, therefore, that its return to power will be facilitated by the Congress' decline under the weight of corruption and policy paralysis may not be fulfilled. Not only has the party failed to fill its leadership vacuum caused by Atal Behari Vajpayee's retirement, it has also been unable to firm up its economic policies as in Vajpayee's time.

As much is evident from the role of a spoiler which it plays in the context of the government's economic initiatives. As the BJP's opposition to foreign investment in the retail sector, and earlier to the Indo-US nuclear deal, shows, it has opportunistically forsaken its traditional rightwing image and taken a leftward turn in the belief that "socialism" still has a future in the country.

But the leadership wrangles, the taint of corruption and absence of clarity on economic issues are blocking the party's forward movement. Whatever impetus the party had acquired from the Ramjanmabhoomi agitation has long been dissipated.

Although the recent upsurge among its cadres helped to bolster several leaders in the states - Modi in Gujarat, Shivraj Singh Chauhan in Madhya Pradesh, Raman Singh in Chhattisgarh - they cannot move to the national level for various reasons, of which Modi's disadvantage is well known.

The others cannot be elevated for two reasons. One is that it will create a vacuum in the states and the other is that their ascent will be resisted by the ambitious Delhi-based leaders - Advani, Jaitley, Sushma Swaraj and others. In a way, therefore, Jaitley's boast about a "galaxy" of leaders is true, but it is a liability rather than an asset.


By Amulya Ganguli


Rating (Votes: )   

blog comments powered by Disqus

Related Articles:
» New Sri Lanka CM calls for army withdrawal
» BJP complains about Rahul's 'divisive politics' remark
» Modi to Rahul: Reveal names of youth in touch with ISI or apologise
» Manmohan’s offer to face CBI in coal scam "meaningless": Prakash Javadekar
» Muzaffarnagar riots left 113 dead: Jamaat
» Apologize, BJP tells Rahul Gandhi
» Sharif says U.S. should mediate in Kashmir issue, despite India’s rejection
» PM's statement on willingness to face CBI meaningless: Yashwant Sinha
» Hooda sermonises the media
» Germany, France demand 'no-spy' agreement with US
» BJP distant from concerns of poor, divides people: Rahul
» Obama apprised of talks with Taliban: Sharif
» Delhi in ICU: Harsh Vardhan
» BJP far removed from concerns of poor: Rahul Gandhi
» Himachal CM to tour BJP stronghold
» Countries should cooperate on child rights: Tirath
» Congress manifesto to have suggestions from all: Rahul
» I too may be killed but I don't care: Rahul Gandhi
» Kenya to attend top Commonwealth meet: Sri Lanka
» Ensure peace in Darjeeling, allow development: Mamata
» France's Hollande seen losing 2017 presidential election: Poll
» Obama tells Sharif to bring Mumbai attackers to book, clamp down on Hafiz Saeed
» I can make dal and keema: Obama tells Sharif
» India, China relations unique in the world: Manmohan Singh
» Merkel complains to Obama about surveillance

Other Articles:
Sun warms up Dharamsala ahead of ODI (26th Jan, 2013)
R-Day's third Bhutan king as chief guest (26th Jan, 2013)
About 108 personalities selected for Padma Awards 2013 (26th Jan, 2013)
Artistes mark Republic Day with tree art (26th Jan, 2013)
Chhattisgarh tribals defy Maoists, attend R-Day (26th Jan, 2013)
Republic Day celebrated in Tamil Nadu (26th Jan, 2013)
Punjab government engineer commits suicide in office (26th Jan, 2013)
President approves 359 defence decorations (26th Jan, 2013)
Three arrested in Delhi for smuggling tiger skin (26th Jan, 2013)
Governor heralds Republic Day fete in Karnataka (26th Jan, 2013)
Trinamool leader Arabul to be in jail till Jan 31 (26th Jan, 2013)
Rashid Khan dedicates Padma Bhushan to people of Bengal (26th Jan, 2013)
Mobile phone services suspended in Kashmir Valley (26th Jan, 2013)
Gang-rape victim wants to withdraw complaint (26th Jan, 2013)
Kashmir governor, chief minister discuss Verma panel report (26th Jan, 2013)
Ten year in jail for minor's rapist in Odisha (26th Jan, 2013)
Patnaik announces Rs.1 kilo rice (26th Jan, 2013)
Use guns to stop eve teasing: Delhi's Lt. governor (26th Jan, 2013)
Three IAF officers conferred Vayu Sena gallantry medals (26th Jan, 2013)
Rahul Dravid, Mary Kom to get Padma Bhushan (26th Jan, 2013)
Sri Lankan president to visit Bodh Gaya (26th Jan, 2013)
Divine Shakti festival launched at Kumbh (26th Jan, 2013)
Scientist Yashpal, Dravid, Mary Kom get Padma honours (26th Jan, 2013)
Maharastra celebrates Republic Day (26th Jan, 2013)
Netaji's daughter pained at controversy over father's death (26th Jan, 2013)

Contact Us | Advertise with Us | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Terms of Use