'Parivar' splits on Mumbai issue - BJP backs RSS, Sena isolated
Monday - Feb 01, 2010, 07:25pm (GMT+5.5)
New Delhi/Mumbai, Feb 1 (IANS) Mumbai for Marathis, or for all Indians? The question drove a deeper wedge in the Sangh Parivar Monday with the BJP backing mentor RSS in saying that nothing should not dilute basic "Indianness" and the Shiv Sena zealously guarding its turf to say that the Mumbai was indeed only for Marathis.
Hoping to maximise on the rift, the Congress was not quiet either. Party spokesperson Abhishek Manu Singhvi said the Bharatiya Janata Party should stand by its words and break off its alliance with the Shiv Sena.
"This hypocrisy is an insult to the intelligence of the people of India. Shiv Sena and BJP have close relations for more than 15 years," he said.
And Home Minister P. Chidambaram projected the government's view when he slammed the Shiv Sena for its exclusionary 'Mumbai for Marathis' stand and said such a "pernicious" thesis had to be rejected. The city belonged to all of India, he said.
While the Congress and the central government's stringent condemnation was nothing new, the Shiv Sena found itself isolated within the Sangh Parivar, the loose conglomeration of Hindu rightwing groups mentored by the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh.
In a categoric rejection of its ally's stand, BJP president Nitin Gadkari said identities based on language, region or religion should not dilute "Indianness".
"All citizens of India may be attached to a particular language, region or religion. These identities have never diluted their Indianness. The BJP will never accept the philosophy that there is a conflict between the two," Gadkari said in a statement here.
He said the BJP had always recognised linguistic, regional and religious identities as a reality, but the "strength of India's unity in diversity is achieved when all these identities eventually converge into a larger national identity of Indianness. There is and can never be a conflict between these."
A day after RSS leader Ram Madhav's unusually candid remarks Sunday when he asked RSS volunteers to try prevent the spread of anti-north India and anti-Hindi feelings in Maharashtra, Gadkari was also backed by other BJP colleagues like Murli Manohar Joshi.
The former BJP president said the Mumbai for Marathis stand was unconstitutional. Lashing out at the Shiv Sena, Joshi said: "This is divisive and the worst example of vote bank politics. No sensible person will ever support such a statement."
Stung by the criticism of its anti-north Indians policy, Shiv Sena executive president Uddhav Thackeray thundered in Mumbai that his party did not need lessons from the RSS.
"We do not need lessons from the RSS, It will be in their interest not to rake up the issue. Our stand on this is not new. Mumbai belongs to Marathis," Thackeray told reporters.
He suggested that instead of criticising the Sena over its stand on the influx of north Indians into Maharashtra, the RSS must focus on the plight of north Indians in Assam or teach Hindi to south Indians.
"It should come clear whether it is the RSS' official position or the personal view of Ram Madhav. Ram Madhav is not the sole voice of the RSS," he said.
What Thackeray did not say was that Madhav's remarks followed RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat's comments a day earlier that Indian citizens had a right to stay and earn their livelihood anywhere in the country.
Mohan Bhagwat, who did not name the Shiv Sena or the breakaway Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), both of which have indulged in competitive politics on the issues of Marathi pride, said: "Language, caste, sub-caste, groups, tribes can be different but all are sons of India."
The latest controversy, raked up by the Maharashtra government's move to give new taxi permits only to those who know how to read, write and speak Marathi, shows no signs of abating. The rift could get wider still, leaving the Shiv Sena and the BJP-RSS on either side.
| Other Articles: |
 |
State Ministers to handle non-internal security matters: Chidambaram (1st Feb, 2010) |
 |
Saffron camp split over `Mumbai for Marathis' (1st Feb, 2010) |
 |
Shiv Sena tells RSS to 'keep off Mumbai' issue (1st Feb, 2010) |
 |
Girl student hit by bus, dies (1st Feb, 2010) |
 |
Fire breaks out at SAIL Chhattisgarh unit (1st Feb, 2010) |
 |
Shah Rukh deserves Nishaan-E-Pakistan: Bal Thackeray (31st Jan, 2010) |
 |
Shiv Sena demonstrates outside Shah Rukh's residence (31st Jan, 2010) |
 |
Will speak to Bhagwat on Mumbai remark: Gadkari (31st Jan, 2010) |
 |
RSS asks volunteers in Maharashtra to protect north Indians (31st Jan, 2010) |
 |
No one is indispensable for the party : Mulayam (31st Jan, 2010) |
 |
Aamir, Shah Rukh '2 Idiots': Shiv Sena (30th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Look up, see the biggest, brightest moon tonight (30th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Private sector international airport to come up in Punjab (30th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Obama steps up nuclear energy commitment, creates commission (30th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Student offers virginity for sale to pay university fees (30th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Memorials will not cost any more money, says Mayawati (30th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Online lottery racket busted, three Nigerians arrested (30th Jan, 2010) |
 |
PCB cancels NOCs for Pak players for IPL (29th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Army Chief orders court martial of Lt Gen Avadesh Prakash (29th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Northeast struggling with backwardness: Meira Kumar (29th Jan, 2010) |
 |
'Mumbai-for-all' remark: Thackeray attacks Mukesh (29th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Indian economy will grow 7.5 percent but with high inflation: RBI (29th Jan, 2010) |
 |
JAC extends deadline on Telangana issue till Feb 7 (29th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Ops to continue till Naxals agree for talks: HM (29th Jan, 2010) |
 |
Four Indian youth attacked in Australia: Media Report (28th Jan, 2010) |
|