8:24 am - Thursday November 20, 2025

Petition in Bombay High Court flags health and safety risks at BMCs new pigeon feeding site

91 Viewed Pallavi Kumar Comments Off on Petition in Bombay High Court flags health and safety risks at BMCs new pigeon feeding site
The Allahabad High Court on Wednesday dismissed the petition of seer Shobhan Sarkar, who had sought directions to the Uttar Pradesh government and the district administration of Fatehpur for allowing excavations in a village where, he believed, huge reserves of gold lay buried. A Division Bench comprising Justices Ashok Bhushan and Vipin Sinha dismissed the petition of Sarkar with the remark "no case has been made out to grant any of the reliefs as claimed in the writ petition". Sarkar had claimed that there was a "hidden gold treasure of about 2,500 tonnes at the bank of river Ganga in village Adampur, Tehsil and District Fatehpur". He had also claimed that he was ready to bear the expenses for carrying out excavations at the site for which he had planned to involve experts from Indian School of Mines, Dhanbad and IIT-Kanpur. However, the court rejected the petition observing that Sarkar had "miserably failed to prove any of his right to claim any permission". Significantly, an excavation was carried out at a village in Unnao district recently following a similar claim made by Sarkar. The seer later on blamed the failure of the operation on his not being "invited" to the site by the excavators.
The Allahabad High Court on Wednesday dismissed the petition of seer Shobhan Sarkar, who had sought directions to the Uttar Pradesh government and the district administration of Fatehpur for allowing excavations in a village where, he believed, huge reserves of gold lay buried. A Division Bench comprising Justices Ashok Bhushan and Vipin Sinha dismissed the petition of Sarkar with the remark "no case has been made out to grant any of the reliefs as claimed in the writ petition". Sarkar had claimed that there was a "hidden gold treasure of about 2,500 tonnes at the bank of river Ganga in village Adampur, Tehsil and District Fatehpur". He had also claimed that he was ready to bear the expenses for carrying out excavations at the site for which he had planned to involve experts from Indian School of Mines, Dhanbad and IIT-Kanpur. However, the court rejected the petition observing that Sarkar had "miserably failed to prove any of his right to claim any permission". Significantly, an excavation was carried out at a village in Unnao district recently following a similar claim made by Sarkar. The seer later on blamed the failure of the operation on his not being "invited" to the site by the excavators.

Petition in Bombay High Court flags health and safety risks at BMCs new pigeon feeding site

## Bombay High Court Hears Challenge to Pigeon Feeding Site Amidst Health and Ecological Concerns

**Mumbai, India** – The Bombay High Court is currently reviewing a petition challenging the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation’s (BMC) decision to establish an interim pigeon feeding site along the Airoli-Mulund creekside. The petition raises significant concerns regarding potential public health hazards and the ecological impact of concentrated pigeon feeding in the designated area.

The BMC’s decision to designate the creekside location for controlled pigeon feeding was intended to address the pervasive issue of uncontrolled feeding across the city. Unmanaged pigeon populations are often cited as contributors to public health problems due to the spread of diseases through droppings and the potential for allergic reactions. Furthermore, the accumulation of pigeon waste can lead to damage to public infrastructure and aesthetic degradation of urban spaces.

However, the petitioners argue that the concentration of pigeon feeding at a single location, even under controlled circumstances, presents its own set of challenges. They contend that the increased density of birds in the area could exacerbate the risk of disease transmission, not only to humans but also to other avian species inhabiting the sensitive creekside ecosystem. The petition further highlights the potential for the accumulation of pigeon droppings to contaminate the soil and water, impacting the delicate balance of the local environment.

The Airoli-Mulund creekside is an ecologically significant area, serving as a vital habitat for a variety of migratory birds and marine life. Environmentalists have expressed apprehension that the introduction of a large, concentrated food source could disrupt the natural food chain and negatively impact the biodiversity of the region. They worry that the influx of pigeons could outcompete native bird species for resources and contribute to the degradation of the creek’s overall ecological health.

The petition also raises questions about the BMC’s risk assessment process prior to establishing the feeding site. It alleges that the corporation failed to adequately consider the potential negative consequences for public health and the environment. The petitioners are seeking a comprehensive review of the decision-making process and a thorough environmental impact assessment to be conducted before the feeding site is allowed to operate permanently.

The court has acknowledged the complexity of the issue, recognizing the need to balance the concerns of public health and environmental protection with the desire to manage pigeon populations effectively. During initial hearings, the court has requested detailed information from the BMC regarding the rationale behind the chosen location, the measures in place to mitigate potential risks, and the long-term sustainability of the feeding program.

The outcome of this legal challenge could have far-reaching implications for how urban wildlife is managed in Mumbai and other cities facing similar challenges. It underscores the importance of a holistic and evidence-based approach to urban planning, one that carefully considers the interconnectedness of human health, environmental sustainability, and the well-being of the urban ecosystem. As the Bombay High Court deliberates, the city watches closely, hoping for a resolution that prioritizes both the health of its citizens and the preservation of its fragile natural environment.


This article was created based on information from various sources and rewritten for clarity and originality.

Don't miss the stories followIndiaVision India News & Information and let's be smart!
Loading...
0/5 - 0
You need login to vote.

System constraints holding back probes into cyber attacks: Digital experts

Related posts